Cookie Thursday 5/22/2025- Going back to where it all began

I am not sure if this is the first cookie I made for Cookie Thursday is a Thing but probably.

It is the cookie of a lot of our childhoods.

It is the fastest cook time, longest dry time of the cookies.

I am, of course, writing about the fudgey no bake cookies.

You know, the chocolate peanut butter haystacks.

If these were in our kitchen growing up, it was gonna be a great day.

Perfect for breakfast with milk. What? They have heart healthy oats AND peanut butter. Perfection.

Perfect for lunches because they travel well.

Perfect for keeping at room temperature because there is nothing in them that can go bad. I’m thinking of you eggs.

If I had to chose a cookie from my childhood to be my absolute ride or die cookie it would be this one.

And the crumbs aren’t so bad either.

In fact, I would hazard to say that the crumbs are the best part. They are certainly the most versatile and can be used in place of granola. Fight me on this one.

Leave a comment